I really like Major Crimes, TNT’s The Closer spin-off featuring Mary McConnell as Captain Sharon Raydor, who’s replacing Deputy Chief Brenda Johnson (Kyra Sedgewick) as the leader of a Los Angeles police unit tasked with investigating murders, kidnappings, and other (drum roll please) major crimes. I’m actually watching the show now, like I never watched The Closer.
And I think I know why.
Under Deputy Chief Johnson’s watch, there was a lot of “we’ll bend and break the rules, but it’s okay, because we’re the good guys.” This escalated to the point of setting a gangbanger up to get killed because they thought he got too sweet a deal for turning state’s evidence. The entire unit, Chief Johnson included, were effectively murderers. How do we sympathize with that? How does the use of police authority and resources for extra-judicial killings not disgust us?
The same kind of self-justifying evil leads to hatred from the pulpit, protests at gay soldiers’ funerals, pepper spraying peaceful protesters, beating suspects even after they’re handcuffed, indefinite detention, and waterboarding at Guantanamo Bay.
It leads a nation to declare its “manifest destiny” to spread “Christian civilization” from the Atlantic to the Pacific, no matter how many “savages” they have to murder along the way. It leads a bunch of good religious folk to yell “we have no king but Caesar” and “crucify him,” until Pontius Pilate washes his hands of it all.
It’s a vile and insidious mindset, one that steals our empathy and threatens our very humanity. Whenever somebody truly believes their side is “the good guys,” everyone outside that group had better beware. Self-righteousness, self-justification, self-idolization … they lead to cruelty, arrogance, and suffering.
This is utterly incompatible with Jesus’ teaching, yet it rings from pulpits and across the Internet. “Slap the gay out of your children,” one preacher says from the pulpit. “Build a fence and lock the gays away,” another preaches. Sure, when it gets that outrageous, people push back, but every day I see anti-gay rhetoric across Facebook and the web. Quieter, sure, less extreme, but possibly uglier in its pervasiveness.
It doesn’t matter if being gay is a sin. As Christians, we are called to be better than the world, to love our neighbors and our enemies [Matthew 5:44] Instead we wallow in the spirit of the worst of the Pharisees, so certain that we’re right that we don’t even try to love our neighbors.
And I can’t stand to see it glorified on cop shows. They stack the premises by making sure we, the audience, know the suspects are guilty. They manipulate our emotions, creating the false dichotomy between “we break the rules to protect you and enforce justice” and “if we followed the rules, the bad guys would go free.”
The problem is in the real world, you don’t know who’s guilty and who’s innocent, not 100%, not ever. Those rules are there to protect the innocent from false accusation, coerced confession, and brutality AND to protect the powerful from becoming corrupt, lazy, self-justifying tools of oppression. And that’s exactly what the Major Crimes unit was under Deputy Chief Brenda Johnson.
But Captain Raydor is the very opposite. Originally introduced in The Closer as a painfully by-the-book foil for the loose cannon unit, she’s not their boss. And she’s made it her mission to make them obey the rules, come hell or high water. She’s just as tough and strong-willed as Brenda was, but she serves the law, rather than acting like a law unto herself. And that’s something I can admire.